Doubtfully Blacklisted: Ralph Bell and Pert Kelton



 Ralph Bell, actor. (Born Ralph Scognamiglio) Arthur Miller claimed that Bell’s wife, actress and noted kook, Pert Kelton had lost her part on the TV show Cavalcade of Stars, where she played the first Mrs. Ralph Kramden of The Honeymooners when it still a 10-20 minute sketch. It became a program in 1955. Kelton was dropped and replaced by Audrey Meadows. The show's producers said that Kelton’s health problems, heart issues, as the reason for her being taken from the show. When the program’s cast went on tour in 1952, Kelton collapsed in Detroit and had to be placed in and an oxygen tent.
The caustic Kelton blamed the loss of the role on Blacklisting, but according to Henry Miller not only was she not political, she never voted in her life. So someone surmised that she had lost the role because Ralph Bell had taken part in a May Day rally on some point in his life. But again, according to Henry Miller, who was Bell’s summer neighbor, Ralph Bell, largely a stage actor up until the 1950s, harbored no political leanings at all.
When Kelton was named in Red Channels, she filed a libel suit against Red Channel’s publishers asking for $3000,000. It was her argument that since she had been named in Red Channels her income ….on an average….had dropped from $15,000 to $46.00 Red Channel’s publishers took her up on the court challenge, and Pelton dropped the suit.    
The fact of the matter is, in show business, one the rumors about ill-health, especially heart issues, starts to make the rounds, careers start to falter. Kelton’s health was never good….she converted to Christian Science to combat her ill-health…and Kelton age at the time, in her fifties, ancient by show business standards, affected her career more than being named in Red Channels did.     


The fact was that Kelton remained on Cavalcade of Stars until its final season. The actor who played the upstairs neighbor, Trixie, was also replaced on the program. Pelton appeared on the TV program The Honeymooners in the 1960s when Alice was played by Shelia Mac Rae, the fourth actor to play that role. Pelton was constantly ill, suffered from seizures and would die suddenly from a heart attack in 1968. Kelton also worked in theater from 1954-1955, the Bad Seed, and from 1957 through 1961 in The Music Man. Basically, she was rarely out of work.


As for Bell, who was named in Red Channels, his record shows that the so-called Blacklist didn’t much affect his career. In 1950 he appeared on the TV program Pulitzer Prize Playhouse, and the series, The Web. In 1951-1955, he portrayed Lt. Travis Rogers on NBC Radio's "Barry Craig, Confidential Investigator" In1952, he appeared on Guiding Light. In 1954, he appeared in the program Inner Sanctum.  In 1956-1957, he appeared on The Edge of Night and The Edge of Night. He was an actor on the 1959 program Deadline. From 1953 through 1961, he wrote scripts and occasionally acted on The Loretta Lynn Show and in 1957, he was a writer on the George Sanders Mystery Theater  He became a national board member of the Screen Actors Guild in early 1965 and remained on the board through 1994.


Just because a person said they were blacklisted doesn’t mean they were. Many people in Hollywood have lied about being blacklisted over the years.
If  a person was actually blacklisted…and not many were actually blacklisted….it was the studios and TV sponsors who blacklisted them. Not the United States federal government.
If a person claims the blacklist ruined their career, they should be able to prove they had a career before the blacklist.